Read Aloud To Children

This blog was created to post reviews for my Children's and Young Adult Literature Class (LS-5603) at Texas Woman's University, where I am currently pursuing a Master's Degree in Library Science.

Tuesday, November 28, 2006

The Giver-- CD AUDIO BOOK


1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA

The Giver

Written by Lois Lowry

Perfomed by Ron Rifkin

Publisher: Listening Library

Publication Date: February 27, 2001

ISBN: 080726203X

2. PLOT SUMMARY

Twelve year old Jonas lives in what many would consider to be a "perfect" world. His community has no crime, sickness, everyone has a job, and all are happy. However, when Jonas is chosen to be the community's next Receiver of Memories, he learns what all has been kept from him in his sheltered world. As he struggles to deal with all he is learning, Jonas must decide if he wants to consider living in a world where there is no color, holidays, or even snow. Once Jonas learns what it means for a community member to be released, he decides to take a risk and break free of the only world he has ever known.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS

First of all, I have always been a big fan of audio books, and I must say this is one of the best readings/performances that I have ever listened to. Ron Rifkin's voice clearly defined each character, and I had no trouble visualizing what was happening in the story. I also loved the use of music as the story was told. The musical interludes were perfect to set an ominous tone for the mysterious setting of the story. Also, the music was light and happy as Jonas received happy memories. The music really help set the mood of the entire novel. I enjoyed listening to this story.

Lois Lowry is a gifted writer, and it is easy to see why she has two Newberry Awards. Her style is simple yet she is able to convey deep meaning in her word choices. She creates a story that is fast paced and hard to quit reading (or listening to) until you have finished the story. THE GIVER certainly was like that for me. I would listen to the story as I drove to and from work, and found myself so into the story, that I often missed my exit more than once! That's a powerful story! The plot was believalbe, and I found myself beginning to wonder if communites like this existed somewhere! As I listened to the story, I found myself pondering many of the book's "big picture" questions. Would it really be a good thing to live in a society where your destiny has already been determined? How would individuals be different if they never experienced pure joy and happiness. This novel would be an awesome one to use with a book club becasue there are so many questions the plot raises in its readers/listeners.

The characters in this story are very believable and well suited for its plot. As Jonas struggled to accept his assignment, I was sympathetic to the issures he faced. My heart ached when Jonas was devasted to learn what it meant when his father "released" a child--"Jonas felt a ripping sensation inside himself, the feeling of terrible pain clawing its way forward to emerge in a cry." Equally believable was The Giver, and I could picture how exhausted this man was from struggling to keep the memories for the community while dealing with his daughter's decision to be released from being the new Memory Keeper. I also saw how caring The Giver was by allowing Jonas to escape and his willingness to stay behind to care for the community that would struggle with Jonas' disappearance.

Lowry's description of the community suited the plot well. I could picture the colorless, drab world (Something that is hard to imagine!) these characters lived in. The style in which this story was told was well suited to its plot also. Having the characters speak such "perfect" language again allowed me to get a true picture of this strange society in which these people lived--how exact and perfect it all had to be for its citizens.

As stated earlier, this novel is full of thought provoking questions that would make an ideal discussion for a literature group. I would use this novel with a group of high readers, and give them plenty of opportunity to discuss and comment on what they read. It would be interested to get many perspectives on this novel, and how they would deal with living in this perfect society.

4. REVIEW EXCERPTS:

From School Library Journal--"This tightly plotted story and its believable characters will stay with readers for a long time."
From AudioFile--"His (Rifkin) voice for the Giver becomes increasingly weary and strained while Jonas' gains strength. Sharing this audiobook in a family or classroom offers a valuable opportunity to respond to and discuss Lowry's moving novel."

5. CONNECTIONS:

*Lowry's descriptions of Jonas' ability to see colors are wonderful. Think about how you could describe the color red to someone who has never been able to see the color before. Write down your description. Does it truly capture the color?
*Finish the story by writng a conversation Jonas might have with the first people he sees when he arrives at his new community.

Monday, November 27, 2006

looking for alaska


1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA

LOOKING FOR ALASKA

Written by John Green

Published by Dutton Books

Publication Date: 2005

ISBN: 0-525-47506-0


2. PLOT SUMMARY

A first year student at Alabama's Culver Creek boarding school, Miles Halter must learn to deal with many challenges--living away from his parents, making new friends, and getting used to the opressive Alabama heat. As he struggles to figure it all out, Miles meets some people along the way who will have a profound impact on his young life. In particular, Chip Martin, his genius roomate and Chip's best friend Alaska Young, will be a special challenge as Miles deals with the impact her short life will have on his.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS

Author John Green does such a fantastic job of creating believable, realistic characters that it is hard to believe this is his first novel. LOOKING FOR ALASKA is full of teenage characters who are dealing with the struggles that plague many teens. Although some of these characters may be a little more "worldly" than your average teen, Green creates characters in whom we see many strengths as well as weaknesses. All of the teens, from main character Miles to genius Chip are portrayed as anguished, struggling teens. One teen in particular who struggles is the title character, Alaska. Early on, the reader gets a sense of Alaska's struggles when she tells Miles, "There are people here with real problems. I've got real problems. Mommy ain't here, so buck up, big guy."

Instead of the story being divided by chapters, it is broken up into a "Before" and "After" section. The story is broken into sections titled, "one hundred twenty-seven days before" and "sixty-two days after." As you read the story, these titles foreshadow a critical event that is coming in the plot (Alaska's death), and Miles's slow struggle of dealing with his sudden loss. I liked this approach to telling the story. It kept the plot moving and prepared the reader for the tragic climax.

The description of Alabama was extremely descriptive. I especially like Miles's lines concerning the heat--"...the sun burned through my clothes and into my skin with a vicious ferocity that made me genuinely fear hellfire." With a description like that, it was obvious that Miles was having a hard time dealing with the heat. I also like how Green described Miles's reaction to an all fried diet..."You can say a lot of bad things about Alabama, but you can't say that Alabamans as a people are unduly afraid of deep fat fryers." I couldn't help but laugh out loud at this bit of profound wisdom from Miles.

Overall, the author told this story in a straightforward style that suited Miles's narration of the novel. There was no question that early on there would be a tragic event that would shake up this small boarding school community. Miles, as the newcomer to Culver Creek was the perfect character to tell this story. While I enjoyed the writing style of John Green, I was disturbed by the story. Not teaching high school, nor being around many high schoolers, I was pretty shocked by some of the things these young adults did in the story. I would be hesitant to put this novel out for just any student to pick up. I feel that a mature, responsible student would enjoy the story, and see the message Green was trying to get across to his readers, but would worry about this book falling into the hands of an irresponsible young adult. One who might read this story and think that because these students did the things they did in the story it would be okay for them to do it to. Overall, I liked the book, and would recommend it to the right reader, but still might want make parents aware of some of the "mature" situations in the story.

4. REVIEW EXCERPT

From School Library Journal: "...place holders sustain the mood of possiblity and forboding, and the story moves methodically to its ambiguous climax. The language and sexual situations are aptly and realistically drawn, but are sophisticated in nature. Miles's narration is alive with sweet, self-deprecating humor, and his obvious struggle to tell the story truthfully adds to his believablity."

5. CONNECTIONS

*Students not familar with the concept of boarding schools could research a few noted ones, and see how similar/different they are compared to Culver Creek.
*Research the state of Alabama. Are John Green's depictions of people from this state accurate/realistic?

Kira-Kira



1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA

KIRA-KIRA

Written by Cynthia Kadohata

Published by Atheneum Books for Young Readers

Publication Date: 2004

ISBN: 0-689-85639-3

2. PLOT SUMMARY

"My sister, Lynn, taught me my first word: kira-kira." So begins the story of two sisters and the love they share for one another. Told through younger sister Katie's point of view, the reader sees not only the love between the two girls, but the struggles of the family as well. Set in the 5o's and 60's, the struggles of this Japanese-American family are brought to life through Katie's voice. As the family grows, they must learn to deal with all things good as well as difficult. Especially when they find out Lynn has a terminal illness. As the family struggles to say good bye to Lynn, Katie works hard to remember Lynn's glittery (kira-kira) outlook on life and remind her grieving family of Lynn's powerful presence will always be a part of their lives.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS:

As I read KIRA-KIRA, I often found myself caught up in this family's struggles. Not only for the heartbreaking loss of their older daughter, but for the injustices this Japanese-American family faced in segregated Georgia. Kadohata created believable characters whom I could sympathize with and grieve with as they coped with the tragedy of Lynn's young death. As Katie began to understand that Lynn was not going to recover from her illness, my heart ached for her. "Then I looked up 'malignant' in the dictionary. It said: Threatening to life; virulent: a mailignant disease. Tending to metastasize, cancerous. Used of a tumor. And that was how I found out Lynn might die." As I read that line, I could picture Katie looking up from the dictionary, a devastated look on her face as she compreheded the defintion. What imagery!

While the story was sad, the plot moved smoothly. Even though I knew the story was most likely not going to end happily, I couldn't put the book down. I had to see how the characters would react to Lynn's death, and struggle to get pass their loss. The author did a great job at establishing the setting. The reader got the feeling that the family was now living in a town where the Japanese-Americans were not welcomed to the neighborhood with open arms. While the author never used the word discrimination, I could feel the entire family's struggle to fit in. Especially Katie, where she had to face harsh words from other children at school. "They think we're like doormats--or ants or something!" Lynn did her best to make Katie understand that not everyone would want to speak to her on her first day of school because of her color.

While the story had many "sad" parts, the mood of the story varied throughout. At times, I was moved to tears, and other times found myself laughing out loud at Katie's antics, (and especially when she talked about how she was developing the southern "drawl.") In the end, as Katie and her family came to accept the fact Lynn was gone, and move on with their lives, I felt happiness for the family and their ability to overcome such a devastating blow to their lives and rejoice in all "kira-kira" Lynn brought to their lives.

4. REVIEW EXCERPTS

From SCHOOL LIBRARY JOURNAL--"All of the characters are believable and well developed, especially Katie, who acts as a careful observer of everything that happens in her family, even though there is a lot she doesn't understand."

From PUBLISHERS WEEKLY--Lynn's ability to teach Katie to appreciate the "kira-kira," or glittering, in everyday life makes this novel shine.

5. CONNECTIONS

*Have students read about the discrimination Japanese-Americans faced in our country during the 50's and 60's. Compare the facts to Kadohata's portrayal of the Takeshima family. Were her descriptions of the struggles the family faced due to their nationality believable?

Friday, November 10, 2006

Bud, Not Buddy

1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA
Bud, Not Buddy

Written by Christopher Paul Curtis

Published by Yearling

Publication Date: (Reprint Edition, 2002)

ISBN: 0-4404-1328-1

2. PLOT SUMMARY
When orphan Bud gets the opportunity to go (as he refers to it) "on the lam," an adventure begins. Determined to track down the man he believes to be his father, Bud encounters several setbacks, but perseveres until he makes to Grand Rapids, finding that man. A discovery about that man will allow Bud to have something he has longed for...a permanent home.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS
If you want to expose children to several important historical events, give them this book. Not only do we learn how the Great Depression impacted Flint, Michigan, we also learn about Civil Rights and labor unions. This fantastic novel is full of historical topics waiting to be learned about and explored even further. Christopher Paul Curtis has created a strong, loveable character in Bud (who refuses to be called Buddy). The reader is immediately drawn to Bud and feels his pain as he experiences joy and sadness. Even when Bud is upset, he is able to hide it from most, telling the reader, "I don't know why, but my eyes don't cry anymore." He also had me laughing outloud many times, especially when he got even with Toddy by making him "pee the bed" before he runs away from the foster home. Bud as well as all the descriptive characters in this book work together to give the reader an idea of how the depression was a struggle for so many. I felt like Bud, as well as all the characters were believable and reacted the way I would have expected someone to act if they were living through/experiencing the same situation the characters faced.

The story takes place in several settings, but no matter where Bud is, the scene is described with such detail, that the reader is taken to that same spot. While I had read in textbooks about the "Hooverville's" that were constructed during the depression, I don't think I had ever "seen" one until Bud described the one outside Flint. I could feel the desperation in the characters when the police showed up to destroy the "cardboard jungle" taking away the only hope many of these characters had. The shelter where Bud is able to get breakfast a couple of mornings, reminded me of the soup lines of the depression. Characters wait to get fed only to have to be reminded of how unfair life is by having to pass a bilboard of a wealthy white family to get their food. The anger many feel about this is expressed by one character, "...you wouldn't expect that they'd have the nerve to come down here and tell the truth." I could feel the frustration as characters tried to work to make a better life for themselves.

The style of this novel reflected the time period, and dialects used by the characters reflected the area the novel was set in. The details regarding the time period were woven in throughout the story so carefully, that many times I felt these were actual people who lived through the depression. It is easy to see that Curtis researched his setting and background for this novel thoroughly. I also liked his afterword when he shared with the reader how he had based two characters on his grandfathers and had even included pictures of them. That made the story much more real and personable to me. Again, I feel this is another book everyone she read!

4. REVIEW EXCERPTS
*From School Library Journal--"...readers will be so caught in the adventure..."
*From Booklist--"Curtis says in an afterword that some of the characters are based on real people...so it's not surprising that the rich blend of tall tale, slapstick, sorrow, and sweetness has the wry, teasing warmth of family folklore"

5. CONNECTIONS
*Read this book and then another book set during the depression in a different area (such as A YEAR DOWN YONDER). Use the two books to challenge students to think about how people were affected differently by the depression depending upon where they lived.
*Bring in Jazz recordings so students can be exposed to the kind of music Bud's grandfather played.
*Research labor unions. Why did they pose a threat to businesses?

A Year Down Yonder

1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA
A Year Down Yonder

Written by Richard Peck

Published by Scholastic

Publication Date: 2000

ISBN: 0-439-32197-2

2. PLOT SUMMARY
As a result of the Great Depression, Mary Alice has come from Chicago to live with her fiesty grandmother. Dreading living and going to school in what Mary Alice calls a "hick town," she must learn to live life at a slower pace. It isn't too long before Mary Alice is Grandma Dowdel's partner in crime, and Mary Alice ends up having one adventurous year with her grandmother that she is sorry to see come to an end.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS
Grandma Dowdel ranks near the top of my "All Time Favorite (Literature) Characters" list! I don't believe I have ever had the pleasure of getting to know such a colorful character through the pages of a book. Grandma Dowdel is definately a person you would want as your friend and not your enemy. The lines Grandma Dowdel delivers in this book are great...from describing a Ina Rae (one of Mary Alice's schoolmates) as "skinny as a toothpick with termites" to telling a WPA painter to give the post office "...two coats...the paint's about the only thing that's holding it up." The dialogue given to Grandma certainly helps create a character who has been hit by hard times, but is recovering well.

The reader quickly learns how resourceful a woman she is during the hard times left behind by the Great Depression. Richard Peck does a fantastic job at describing the setting and telling of the small town hardships people faced as they recovered from economic setback in 1937. From collecting pecans and pumpkins from neighbors' homes (without their knowledge) to helping the Daughters of the American Revolution with their annual Washington Tea, you can get a sense of how people helped each other out during this time period. How the neighbors turned out to help a fellow citizen is so beautifully presented in the chapter, "A Minute in the Morning" when the town comes to the aid of Mrs. Abernathy by holding a turkey shoot and selling mugs of burgoo to help raise money for her to care for her invalid son, wounded in the Great War. (And with Grandma doing the selling, she makes sure that everyone who can gives more than their fair share.)

After reading this book, I felt I had a good picture of what life was like for the citizens of a small town recovering from the depression. Peck's wonderful description of the setting and colorful characters stayed with me long after I read this book. I found myself laughing out loud many times as I read about how Grandma Dowdel out foxed many of the town's citizens. (My favorite scene? The description of a naked Maxine Patch running out of Grandma's house with only a snake wrapped around her body...that is the best!) This Newberry Award winner should be experienced by all!

4. REVIEW EXCERPTS
*From Booklist--"Richard Peck's Newbery Award winner is a multi-layered story of small town life spiced with humor, love, and a bit of history."
*From Publisher's Weekly--"hilarious and poignant"

5. CONNECTIONS
*Students research FDR's New Deal programs mentioned in the book--the WPA and the CCC. How did programs like these help the country get back on it's feet?
*Read the prequal to this book, A LONG WAY FROM CHICAGO. How does the story change with Joey telling it instead of Mary Alice? What do you think A YEAR DOWN YONDER would have been like if Joey had been the narrator instead of Mary Alice?

Thursday, November 09, 2006

The Midwife's Apprentice


1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA
The Midwife's Apprentice

Written by Karen Cushman

Publisher: HarperTrophy

Publication Date: 1995

ISBN: 0-06-440630-X

2. PLOT SUMMARY
A young, homeless girl is taken in by the local midwife after being found asleep in a dung heap in the woman's barn. Named "Beetle" by the woman, the girl becomes an apprentice to her in exchange for food and a place to sleep. As the story develops, so does Beetle's belief in herself. She gives herself a name, Alyce, and works to develop the self confidence needed to one day become a midwife herself. Set in medieval England, this 1996 Newberry Award winner hooks the reader with the first page.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS
Although medieval European history has never been a strong interest of mine, I was captivated by this slim novel. Since I did not have a strong background in this particular area of history, I was dependent on the novel's strong description of the setting and time period. Cushman did not disappoint me, and even managed to teach me a thing or two about medieval England and the practices of midwives during this time. A vivid picture of the street market came to my mind as I read the chapter describing Alyce's trip to town. The essence of this time period came alive through Cushman's description of the scene..."She passed through the forest of bright booths with flags and pennants flying, offering for sale every manner of wonderous things--copper kettles, rubies and pearls, ivory tusks from mysterious animals, cinnamon and ginger from far away lands, tin from Cornwall, and bright green woollen cloth from Lincoln." I could picture the market and feel Alyce's excitement at being amongst the magnificent goods the merchants had to share. Cushman's descriptions are so vivid, that at times I felt as if I had been transported back in time and was actually there with Alyce as she walked the English countryside.

Alyce is a very strong character. As the story develops, Cushman allows the reader to witness Alyce's growth from an awkward, shy urchin to a young lady with a passion to learn and become a compassionate midwife. The dialect and customs of this time period are portrayed with accuracy, and it is evident that Cushman researched every aspect of medieval history to create such an outstanding portrayal of life during this time. Alyce is one of the strongest characters I have met in a novel, and she would be a great role model to other girls to show how far you can rise above a rough beginning when you have develop confidence and begin to believe in yourself.

4. REVIEW EXCERPTS:
From BOOKLIST--"From the first page you're caught by the spirit of the homeless, nameless waif, somewhere around 12 years old, 'unwashed, unnourished, unloved, and unlovely,' trying to keep warm in a dung heap."

From SCHOOL LIBRARY JOURNAL--"Characters are sketched briefly but with telling, witty detail, and the very scents and sounds of the land and people's occupations fill each page as Alyce comes of age and heart."

5. CONNECTIONS:
*Make sure students understand the concept of an "apprentice," and why it would be important for a young girl such as Alyce with no education or family to become an apprentice and learn a trade.
*Research some of the beliefs and practices medieval midwives had/used. How are they different from some of the beliefs and practices of midwives today?
*Students could illustrate/make a model of the street market Alyce visited.

Thursday, October 26, 2006

Leonardo da Vinci


1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA
Leonardo da Vinci

Written and Illustrated by Diane Stanley

Published by Morrow Junior Books

Published 1996

ISBN 0-688-10437-1

2. PLOT SUMMARY
The life and times of one of the great Italian artists and inventors is chronicled in this biography by Diane Stanley. Important contibution da Vinci made to the art world are included as well as background information concerning the art. Colorful, detailed illustrations that incorporate some of da Vinci's art help to transport the reader to the Italian Renaissance as they read about this extraordinary man's life.

3. CRITICAL ANANLYSIS
I am ashamed to admit it, but prior to reading this book, much of what I knew about da Vinci was from reading Dan Brown's THE DA VINCI CODE. This book helped to fill in the gaps. I learned many interesting facts about the man who is mainly remembered for his art, especially the Mona Lisa. While I did know that he was quite an inventor, I did not have any idea how far ahead of his time he was with many of his ideas. Stanley shares many sides of this interesting man in her biography. The writing is descriptive as are the detailed illustrations. I particularly liked how Stanley included many of da Vinci's paintings into her illustrations. This helped the reader become familar with da Vinci's style and art work. Not only does the reader learn about da Vinci's life, but they learn to identy much of his artwork through the illustrations.

I also liked how Stanley's biography of da Vinci had a "story like" feel to the reader. The introduction was inviting, "In the spring of 1452, Antonio da Vinci, aged eighty, took out a leather-bound volume." This hooks the reader into the story of da Vinci's life and draws them into his intriguing life story.

4. REVIEW EXCERPTS
*From School Library Journal--"The text is readable and interesting; the authour is careful to distinguish between facts and surmises, and uses quotes from Leonardo's own writing to demonstrate his attitudes."
*From Booklist--"Well researched, intelligently written, and beautifully illustrated, this is the best of the many children's books on Leonardo."

5. CONNECTIONS
*The illustrations could be used to introduce students to some of Leonardo's artwork.
*Pair this book with LEONARDO'S HORSE by Jean Fritz to expose students to the full story regarding da Vinci's attempt to sculpt a statue of Francesco Sforza.

Animals Nobody Loves


1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA
Animals Nobody Loves

Written by Seymour Simon

Published by Sea Star Books

Published 2001

ISBN 1-58717-079-5

2. PLOT SUMMARY
If you have ever squealed or screamed when you have come in contact with a not so pleasant animal, then you might want to steer clear of this Seymour Simon title. Simon has written short pieces about some of our animal friends that are a little harder to love, and paired them with photographs of the creatures that look like they are about to attack the reader. This book is sure to grab the attention of the most reluctant reader and keep it until the last page is read.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS
Using concise, well-written sentences, Simon has managed to say a lot about some not so loveable animal beasts. All animal groups are represented from rodents (rats) to fish (piranhas). Many memorable facts are included in each description of the animals featured. I learned many new things about animals that I had been reluctant to investigate. Simon's facts pulled me into the descriptions of each animal so deeply that I forgot to be frightened! I'm sure I will find myself repeating many of the facts I learned from this engaging book. Facts such as..."Some sharks can bite three hundred times harder than a human.", and "Roaches can run as fast as three miles an hour."

Another compelling feature of this book is the excellent photographs Simon has included with each animal description. The photographs include the details of some of the animals' "unloveable" features. The pictures help enhance the learning and pull the reader into the descriptions of the highlighted animals.

4. REVIEW EXCERPTS
*From Booklist--"The pictures are fine, large, and in full color, as fascinating as they are repulsive and scary: the yawning jaws of a shark; a hyena consuming bloody food; a wasp enlarged bigger than a human fist, stinging a grasshopper. Simon puts forward some interesting facts and dispels a few myths about these 20 unlovable subjects..."

5. CONNECTIONS
*While the writing accompanying each picture wouldn't provide much information for a report, each description would be a great starting point for a research project for each of the subjects in the book. After sharing the book with students, they could select one animal to investigate/research further, and then share their findings with the class.
*The short informational narratives would be great examples to use with students who are beginning to learn how to read nonfiction.

Monday, October 23, 2006

An American Plague


1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA
An American Plague
The True and Terrifying Story of the the Yellow Fever Epidemic of 1793

Written by Jim Murphy

Published by Clarion Books

Published 2003

ISBN 0-395-77608-2

2. PLOT SUMMARY
Imagine you are a resident of Philadelphia in 1793. A mysterious killer is running rampant on the streets outside, and you are powerless to stop it. It could strike you at any time! An American Plague puts you right in the center of Philadelphia during the midst of a deadly Yellow Fever epidemic. Residents were powerless to stop this killer, and before they even had a vague clue as to what had hit the city, hundreds of residents were dead. Thousands would be gone before it was all over. This fast paced account of the epidemic takes readers back to the days when this deadly predator lurked amongst the homes of Philadelphia.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS
At times, this non-fiction account of one of the deadliest plagues to ever hit Philadelphia read like a great mystery novel! With lines like, "Friday, August 20. The deathly quiet of this Friday morning was shattered by the sharp, echoing boom of a cannon." starting off a chapter, what reader couldn't help but be pulled in? Informational text has certainly changed from when I was in school. If there had of been more books as well written as this one, I might have finally ventured away from the fiction shelf! Jim Murphy paints a grisly scene as he describes the bleak outcome for many of the residents of Philadelphia in 1793. Descriptive accounts of fever symptoms and how affected patients reacted to the disease, left clear visualizations in my mind. While I was aware of this epidemic, Murphy's well-researched book gave me such a vast amount of information on the subject, that I now feel like an expert on the subject! However, for all of the detail Murphy used to describe the epidemic, I never once felt "bogged down" by all of the facts. Many informational books throw one fact after another at the reader as they read, that they overwhelm you with the information, until you are left with a pile of useless information that you can't really tie together. Murphy does not do this. His book read well, and each new bit of information flowed smoothly into the next, and the reader was able to see how all of the events of the Yellow Fever epidemic worked together to create one of the greatest disasters in Philadelphia. Illustrations and copies of newspaper accounts from the time period worked together to allow the reader to connect to this event from our past. An informative and interesting read!

4. REVIEW EXCERPTS
*From School LIbrary Journal (Starred Review)--"solid research and a flair for weaving facts into fascinating stories...extensive and interesting...you'll have students hooked on history."
*From Booklist--"History, science, politics and public health come together in this dramatic account...brings the "unshakeable unease chillingly close."

5. CONNECTIONS
*I WISH I would have had this book several years ago when my fifth grade class read Fever, 1793 by Laurie Halse Anderson. The deeper understanding my students could have had of the fever and its impact on Philadelphia would have been incredible. I definately recommend pairing the two books together for a great literature study.
*Students could write a newspaper article to inform readers how to keep from getting the disease, and how to recognize the symptoms.

Friday, October 13, 2006

make lemonade


1. BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATA
make lemonade

Written By Virginia Euwer Wolff

Published by Henry Holt and Co., LLC

Published 1993

ISBN 978-0-8050-8070-4

2. PLOT SUMMARY
Jolly is a seventeen year old single mother of two children by different fathers. Seeking help with babysitting, she posts a notice at fourteen year old LaVaughn's school. Wanting to earn money for college, LaVaughn becomes Jolly's baby sitter. Together, these two struggling teens work to discover how hard it can be to reach a goal, or just to set one. Told in free-verse, from LaVaughn's point of view, this tender story is one you won't soon forget.

3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS
This concise, poetic novel packs more of a punch than many books twice it's size. Told through the eyes of LaVaughn, a strong, determined fourteen year old, Virginia Wolff uses tight phrases with just the right words to draw the reader into the story. I quickly became wrapped up in LaVaughn's character. A young girl who has already witnessed more tragedy than she should of in her life, but still is determined to go to college to have a better life. Jolly's character is hard to forget as well, and Wolff shows readers that being a mother of two children at age seventeen is not an easy task.

While I have read many excellent free-verse, poetic novels, this book would be close to the top of the list as being one of the best. I am in awe of Wolff's ability to create such imagery with so few words. When describing Jolly's unkept apartment, one could almost feel the dirt and grime beneath their feet. Phrases like, "...a gooey baby in her arms and something gurgles out of that one's nose..." brought images of poor "ragamuffin" children to my mind. I believe if this novel had of been written out in prose form, many of the strong visual images would have been lost on the reader. Wolff's excellent word choice and rhythm made this novel a wonderful read.

4. REVIEW EXCERPTS
*From School Library Journal--"With warmth, humor, and a voice blending street smarts and innocent naivete, Simms' melodious words draw listeners into the world of unwed parenthood, the struggle for a better life, and teh deepening friendship between LaVaughn and Jolly."
*From Kirkus Reviews--"LaVaughn's narrative--brief, sometimes ungrammatical sentences in uneven lines, like verse--is in a credible teenage voice suited to readers like Jolly herself; yet it has the economy and subtlety of poetry."

5. CONNECTIONS
*The imagery in this novel begs for illustration. Share several of the descriptive phrases with students, have them select one and sketch the visualization it brings to mind.
*Students could research different school programs for unwed mothers like the program Jolly is participating in. How are they alike and different. Students could then design a brochure to give to interested teenage mothers to inform them about the program they researched.